Healthcare Providers Score Significant Supreme Court Victory

By Cindy Amedee
Partner, Taylor Porter
cindy.amedee@taylorporter.com

Click here to read complete Supreme Court ruling

Today's unanimous United States Supreme Court ruling in Universal Health Srvs., Inc. v. United States ex rel. Escobar, U.S. scored a victory for healthcare providers as the Court reversed a court of appeals ruling in favor of two False Claims Act (FCA) whistle-blowers who alleged that a mental health facility submitted false Medicaid claims.

Escobar began in the District of Massachusetts. Julio Escobar and Carmen Correa alleged that their daughter, Yarushka River, who died of a seizure in 2009, was treated by unlicensed and unsupervised staff at Arbor Counseling Services, owned and operated by defendant Universal Health Services. The suit was filed in 2011, contending that UHS violated the FCA, the Massachusetts False Claims Act, and various Massachusetts regulations by submitting bills for staff members who were not properly licensed and/or supervised, and by submitting bills during a time when Arbor did not employ a fully-certified psychiatrist and a fully-certified psychologist.

The whistle-blowers and government attorneys argued that the facility falsely implied its certification with applicable federal regulations in submitting reimbursement claims for treatment. But the Court, in a decision authored by Justice Clarence Thomas, rejected an expansive reading of FCA liability, saying that noncompliance with federal regulations may only result in FCA liability if compliance is material to the government's decision to pay.

The ruling turns on whether non-compliance with federal regulations is material to a government health plan's decision to pay a claim for treatment submitted by a health care provider to the government payor. The ruling also gives healthcare providers a wall of defense against an increasing trend of FCA whistle-blower complaints, which carry the possible burden of big money damages, and signals that the FCA must be more strictly interpreted.

For more information about this ruling and other pressing healthcare legal issues that affect your business, please do not hesitate to contact any of our attorneys on
Taylor Porter’s Healthcare Practice Team.

Disclaimer & Privacy

This website is for general information purposes only. Information posted is not intended to be legal advice. For more information, please see our Disclaimer message.

Share this Post:

See how we can help. Contact us today

8th Floor • 450 Laurel Street • Baton Rouge, LA 70801 • 225-387-3221

  • Disclaimer
  • © Taylor, Porter, Brooks & Phillips L.L.P. All rights reserved.